I liked the basic idea and characters in the story but I didn't like how it was told. I think it should have been from just Gabriels POV or Mariah's POV not both. I Found this distracting and choppy. I feel like I have a lot of questions still not answered. Chaplin was hard to get used to. Once I got the thought in my head that he reminded me of the talking dog in the movie up it was all wrong for me. I had to make myself finish the book in the end. It is sad because I thought it would be a series I could really get into.